Whenever I make a dessert or cookie, my first inclination is to choose something with chocolate. Otherwise, what is the point of all that work and calories? But my second choice would be something with lemon. Anything flavored with the little yellow citrus fruit just seems really refreshing, and seems to be liked by everyone.
So when I promised to make a batch of cookies for the Barber Institute table at the Millcreek Mall Chocolate Chase, Hilary Matthews’ recipe for Lemon Cookies really caught my eye. Plus, I thought that it would give those who don’t care for chocolate another tasty option.
I will admit that I was a bit skeptical when I saw the recipe. I mean, it only has three ingredients (not counting the powdered sugar you dust on after baking). But I just happened to have the first ingredient, a box of lemon cake mix, so I forged ahead. After adding eggs and canola oil, I had a cookie batter.
As instructed, I dropped spoonfuls onto the baking sheet. I don’t know why I expected to end up with a ball cookie, but this batter really spreads when cooking. That’s okay, just don’t put them too close together. The recipe says they cook quickly—8 to 10 minutes—and that is certainly true. The cookies were best with a slightly golden color around the sides.
I only had about an hour between getting home from work and heading off to an evening appointment, but I managed to get these cookies assembled, baked and out of the oven in plenty of time. These treats were light and fluffy with a perfect mix of the tart and sweet. A real delight—even for the most dedicated chocolate lover!
By Mary Cuneo








